Introduction
Tuberculosis (TB) continues to be a significant global health burden, particularly in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), where it remains a major public health challenge [
1‐
3]. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that SSA alone accounts for a disproportionate 25% of the world’s TB cases [
4]. TB transmission within and between households is a critical concern in the region, as individuals in close contact with TB patients are at a heightened risk of acquiring the infection and subsequently spreading it to others in the community [
5]. This underscores the importance of understanding the involvement of family members in managing TB for affected individuals. Thus, family decisions and support have substantial ramifications for disease transmission and control, as well as the overall well-being and treatment results of TB patients [
6].
Evidence shows that TB-related stigma is pervasive in several SSA communities, driving individuals to hide their TB status to avoid discrimination and isolation [
7]. The fear of social “ostracization” can heavily influence a family or individual’s choice to conceal their TB status or the status of their family members, thereby impeding contact tracing efforts and TB case identification within and between households [
8]. This can lead to delayed diagnosis, delayed treatment initiation, and further transmission of the disease, as a result, exacerbating the burden of the disease [
9]. It is therefore essential to develop comprehensive strategies that focus on destigmatising TB and promoting open communication about the disease. By creating supportive environments, individuals may feel more comfortable disclosing their TB status, seeking timely diagnosis and treatment, and ultimately contributing to better overall TB control in the region.
Intention to conceal the TB status of family members is crucial to the disease’s spread and control and may involve individuals intentionally hiding their TB symptoms or diagnosis from their relatives and the community, or family members deciding to keep the TB status of a family member a secret from the community [
10,
11]. While evidence shows that these behaviours might stem from the fear of stigmatisation and discrimination [
10], it is crucial to investigate the extent to which various social determinants are linked to these decisions. Investigating the social determinants associated with family decisions to conceal TB status holds significant importance for several reasons. Firstly, comprehending the underlying socio-economic factors driving TB concealment can enable the design of targeted interventions to address these issues effectively. By addressing the root causes, public health initiatives can enhance TB transmission control and improve treatment outcomes. Secondly, socio-economic disparities can create vulnerable populations more inclined to conceal TB status. Identifying these at-risk groups can assist healthcare providers and policymakers in allocating resources and customising interventions to cater to those most in need. Lastly, understanding the socio-economic context can empower healthcare providers to deliver patient-centred care, acknowledging the distinct challenges and requirements of individuals and families impacted by TB.
Despite the significance of understanding the social determinants associated with intentions to conceal TB status in SSA, limited research has been conducted on this topic. The closest study to date was carried out in Ghana approximately seven years ago [
10]. The scarcity of previous research on this topic, the considerable time gap since the nearest study, and the absence of studies encompassing variables across multiple countries emphasise the urgent need for an extensive investigation into the social determinants that drive individuals’ choices to conceal their TB status in SSA. Such research will be critical for unveiling nuanced insights into the multifaceted socio-cultural, economic, and health-related factors that underpin TB status concealment in the region. This study, therefore, aimed to examine the socio-demographic and economic factors associated with the intention to keep TB status concealed among family members in seven SSA countries using two response categories- “Yes” or “No”. Based on the evidence in several studies [
11‐
14], we hypothesised that the intention to conceal TB status among family members would demonstrate significant associations with variables, such as age, sex, marital status, place of residence, education, religion, exposure to media, and wealth. Our approach offers two significant contributions to the existing literature. Firstly, it enhances the methodological approach utilised in the previous research [
10]. Secondly, it expands the research scope from a single country to encompass seven countries with relevant data. Unravelling these complexities holds the key to targeted interventions, support systems, and stigma reduction strategies that can transform TB management and care in the included countries.
Discussion
The study aimed to examine the factors associated with the intention to conceal the TB status of family members. We found that more than a quarter of the sample (28%) admitted to intending to conceal the TB status of their family members. This elevated prevalence of TB status concealment intentions for family members highlights the necessity for targeted public health policies and interventions. Policymakers can prioritise enhancing community awareness and knowledge regarding TB, emphasising early diagnosis, treatment adherence, and transparent communication about TB status. Addressing the stigmatisation linked to TB is essential to foster an environment where individuals and families feel comfortable disclosing their TB status without fear of discrimination. By addressing these aspects, public health policies can play a pivotal role in mitigating TB status concealment intentions and improving TB control efforts.
Given the considerable prevalence of TB status concealment intentions for family members in this sample, it becomes imperative to explore the underlying factors driving such behaviours. Consistent with existing research that underscores the influence of socio-demographic factors on TB status concealment within households [
10,
21‐
23], our findings reveal variations in TB status concealment intentions for family members based on participant’s age, education levels, residence, wealth status, and exposure to mass media. These associations shed light on the determinants of TB status concealment and emphasise the need for further investigation to inform targeted interventions and public health strategies.
More specifically, the findings show that increasing age is associated with a decreased likelihood of intentions to conceal the TB status of family members, which is consistent with a study conducted by Amo-Adjei [
10] in Ghana, where older age groups were less likely to conceal their TB status. This pattern may be attributed to greater health awareness and responsibility among older individuals, leading to a higher likelihood of open communication regarding TB status [
24]. As individuals age, they tend to accumulate more health-related experiences and knowledge [
25], leading to heightened awareness of the importance of timely TB diagnosis and treatment. Consequently, older individuals may be more inclined to openly disclose the TB status of their family members to seek appropriate medical care. Moreover, their familiarity with TB, either through personal experiences or knowledge of affected family or friends, may reduce fear or stigma associated with the disease, making them more willing to share the TB status of their family members openly. Furthermore, older individuals often hold significant roles within their families, and concealing the TB status of their family members could adversely impact the health of their household [
26]. Recognising the potential risks of TB transmission to loved ones, older individuals may prioritise open communication about the TB status of family members to safeguard their entire family’s well-being. Additionally, with age, individuals may develop a greater acceptance of health conditions and become more open about their health status [
27], extending this acceptance to disclose the TB status of family members and contributing to the decreased likelihood of concealment. Lastly, older individuals may display reduced concern about social stigma related to TB compared to younger age groups due to having a more stable social network and established relationships [
28], which mitigates fears of discrimination or social isolation if the TB status of other family members becomes known.
Education is a crucial factor in promoting health literacy and increasing awareness of the importance of early TB diagnosis and treatment [
29]. The present study shows that individuals with higher education levels are more likely to understand the potential consequences of TB concealment and, therefore, may be more inclined to disclose the TB status of their family members. Similar to our findings, a study by Agho et al. in Nigeria [
30] and Amo-Adjei in Ghana [
10] also reported that higher educational attainment was associated with a reduced likelihood of concealing TB status. Higher education levels are often associated with improved health literacy [
31], providing individuals with a deeper understanding of health conditions, such as TB and the importance of early detection and treatment. This heightened awareness may lead educated individuals to openly communicate about their TB status with their family members. Moreover, individuals with higher education levels typically have better access to information [
32], healthcare resources, and medical services. This advantage may stem from formal health education or better access to reliable health information sources [
32], influencing their inclination to disclose the TB status of family members. Additionally, higher education equips individuals with better communication skills [
33], enabling them to express themselves effectively and discuss sensitive health issues like TB confidently with their family members. Furthermore, higher education can foster a broader perspective and reduce stigma associated with TB. Educated individuals often demonstrate open-mindedness and understanding of health conditions [
34], making them more willing to share the TB status of their family members without fear of discrimination or social isolation. Lastly, higher education empowers individuals to take charge of their family’s health and advocate for their well-being [
34]. Educated individuals may feel more empowered to openly discuss the TB status of their family members and proactively support them in seeking appropriate medical care.
Furthermore, the results demonstrate a notable association between living in rural areas and a decreased probability of TB status concealment intentions compared to urban areas. This finding of decreased probability of TB status concealment among people living in rural areas compared to urban areas can be influenced by multiple factors. First, rural communities tend to have closer-knit social networks and a stronger sense of community [
35], fostering an environment of trust and support among neighbours and community members. This heightened sense of solidarity may encourage individuals to be more willing to openly disclose the TB status of family members. Moreover, in rural areas, the smaller population and closer social ties may limit opportunities for anonymity. As a consequence, concealing the TB status of family members becomes more challenging, as health-related information can spread quickly within the community, making it difficult to maintain secrecy. Furthermore, limited access to healthcare facilities and resources in rural areas may lead individuals to rely more heavily on their community for support and assistance [
36]. As a result, there may be a greater emphasis on open communication about health issues, including TB, within rural settings. In contrast, urban settings can sometimes be more impersonal and anonymous [
36], which might foster an environment where individuals feel more inclined to conceal their health conditions, including TB, to avoid potential stigmatisation. Additionally, differences in health literacy between rural and urban populations could also play a role [
37]. In rural areas, individuals may have a better understanding of TB and its consequences, leading to greater awareness and openness about the condition [
37]. Nevertheless, these findings contradict the outcomes of both Nyangoma et al.’s study [
22] in Uganda and Nagarajan et al.’s study [
8] in Chennai, where they reported a higher likelihood of TB status concealment among rural residents in comparison to those living in urban areas. This discrepancy could be attributed to variations in cultural norms or differences in the statistical power between the two study settings.
The study also revealed significant associations between religious affiliations and TB status concealment intentions, which is consistent with findings from Ngamvithayapong-Yanai et al. [
38] in Thailand. Their research observed that specific religious beliefs, such as prayer and spirituality, and trust in God’s or Allah’s will, influenced health-seeking behaviours related to TB, potentially impacting the likelihood of concealing the TB status of family members. Health authorities and policymakers can devise awareness campaigns and educational initiatives targeted at specific religious beliefs linked to TB. Such efforts would aim to dispel misconceptions and foster open communication about TB within religious communities, thereby encouraging individuals to disclose their TB status more openly. Culturally sensitive healthcare delivery is essential, necessitating healthcare providers’ awareness of the cultural and religious context when discussing TB with patients and families. By emphasising the significance of early diagnosis and treatment while respecting religious beliefs, a supportive environment for TB disclosure and management can be cultivated. Engaging religious leaders in TB awareness and prevention endeavours can prove pivotal in reaching community members. Given their influential position within congregations, religious leaders’ support can promote health-seeking behaviours related to TB and combat the associated stigma. Additionally, the study highlights the importance of further research to investigate how religious beliefs influence TB-related health-seeking behaviours. Comparative studies across diverse regions and cultural contexts will deepen our understanding of the impact of religious affiliations on TB status concealment. This knowledge will contribute to more effective TB control strategies and culturally appropriate healthcare interventions.
Regarding wealth index, our findings align with previous research conducted in Malawi [
21], Ethiopia [
39], and Ghana [
10] which reported that higher wealth index status was associated with a reduced TB status concealment. Individuals with greater financial resources may have better access to healthcare services, leading to early disclosing, and timely initiation of TB treatment. Individuals with higher financial resources are more likely to have improved access to healthcare facilities and services, enabling them to promptly seek medical attention for TB symptoms, leading to earlier diagnosis and treatment. This timely access to healthcare may reduce the need or motivation to conceal the TB status of family members. Moreover, higher wealth status is often associated with better health awareness and education. Those with greater financial resources tend to have a better understanding of the significance of early detection and treatment for TB, resulting in an increased willingness to openly discuss their TB status with family members. Furthermore, individuals with higher financial resources may have greater exposure to diverse social environments and interactions, potentially leading to reduced stigma associated with TB. The presence of a more inclusive and open-minded social circle may encourage individuals to disclose the TB status of family members without fear of discrimination. In addition, higher wealth status facilitates access to supportive networks and resources, including family, friends, or organisations that promote health-seeking behaviours and discourage concealing TB status. Moreover, greater financial resources empower individuals to make informed decisions about their health. This empowerment may lead to a stronger sense of control over their health outcomes and a greater willingness to openly communicate about the TB status of family members. Additionally, higher wealth status is often linked to better living conditions, including access to clean environments and adequate healthcare facilities. These improved living conditions can contribute to overall better health, reducing the need for individuals to hide the TB status of their family members.
Our findings support prior research [
40] that found a link between mass media exposure and TB status concealment. The connection between mass media exposure and TB status concealment intentions can be attributed to the pervasive influence of media platforms in shaping societal perceptions, norms, and behaviours [
41,
42]. Mass media, through its extensive reach and diverse communication channels, often disseminates information, attitudes, and beliefs about health-related matters, including infectious diseases like tuberculosis [
43]. Exposure to media messages, whether through television, radio, social media, or other mediums, can significantly impact individuals’ understanding and attitudes toward TB [
43]. Misconceptions, stigma, and fear associated with TB may be perpetuated or reinforced by media portrayals, potentially leading individuals to feel compelled to hide the TB status of family members due to concerns about discrimination, social isolation, or other negative consequences [
44]. Furthermore, media campaigns or coverage that lacks accurate information or promotes stigmatising narratives about TB might contribute to fostering an environment where individuals feel inclined to conceal the TB status of their family members as a coping mechanism, influenced by the societal perceptions perpetuated through media exposure [
40,
45]. People’s understanding and behaviours surrounding TB are influenced by media exposure, perhaps lowering stigma and boosting disclosure within families [
40,
45]. Campaigns in the media aim to de-stigmatise TB, promote early diagnosis and treatment adherence, and underline the importance of reporting TB status for optimal disease management [
44]. To this end, our study showed a link between mass media exposure and TB status concealment intentions, emphasising the significance of this component. However, further study is needed to evaluate how the media influences TB disclosure behaviours.
In terms of country-specific variations, our study found significant disparities in TB status concealment across different countries in SSA. Individuals in Ghana, Lesotho, Malawi, Namibia, and Sao-Tome and Principe had higher odds of intentions to conceal the TB status of family members compared to Eswatini. These findings suggest that contextual factors and country-specific healthcare policies may influence TB disclosure practices within households. This result corroborates with past research on cultural epidemiology [
46], which found that long-standing community beliefs about a given disease are the source of regional variability in community perceptions of that disease.
Overall, the findings highlight the importance of targeted policies and interventions to address TB status concealment within specific demographic and socio-economic groups. Tailoring awareness campaigns, involving community leaders, and providing equal access to healthcare services can collectively contribute to reducing TB status concealment and improving TB control in the population.
Limitations of the study
The present study offers valuable insights into the factors associated with TB status concealment intentions among individuals aged 10–49 years in seven SSA countries. However, it is essential to acknowledge certain limitations that may impact the interpretation and generalisability of the findings. One primary limitation of this study is its cross-sectional design, which precludes us from establishing causal relationships between the identified factors and TB status concealment intentions. To better understand the temporal relationships and determine the direction of associations, longitudinal studies would be more suitable. Additionally, the use of self-reported data on TB status concealment intentions may introduce social desirability bias. Respondents might be inclined to provide socially acceptable responses, leading to potential underestimation or overestimation of the practice. Future research could benefit from incorporating objective measures or alternative data sources to validate self-reported information. Furthermore, the DHS data utilised in this study were limited to individuals aged 10–49 years, which might not fully represent TB status concealment intentions among younger or older age groups. Including a broader age range in future studies would enhance the generalisability of the results. Another notable limitation is the absence of specific cultural variables in the analysis, which might be strongly associated with TB concealment intentions. Cultural beliefs, norms, and practices related to TB could significantly impact disclosure behaviours. Another significant limitation of this study pertains to the use of datasets characterised by substantial temporal gaps between their collection dates and the current timeframe. The disparity in the dataset timelines may substantially affect the validity and relevance of the conclusions drawn from this study, as well as the proposed recommendations. This discrepancy may raise concerns about the applicability of findings to the present context, given the potential shifts in social, economic, and health-related dynamics over time, which might not be adequately captured by the data from dissimilar timeframes.
Future research should consider incorporating cultural factors to provide a more comprehensive understanding of TB status concealment. Moreover, despite adjusting for several potential confounding variables, other unmeasured factors may influence TB status concealment. Unaccounted variables might lead to residual confounding and affect the observed associations. Further studies employing a more extensive set of covariates could mitigate this limitation. Additionally, the data utilised in this study were obtained from specific regions or countries, limiting the generalisability of the findings to other populations or settings. Researchers should exercise caution when applying these results to different contexts and consider conducting similar studies in diverse populations.
Despite these limitations, the current study contributes valuable insights to the understanding of TB status concealment intentions. By acknowledging these challenges, we hope to encourage future research that addresses these limitations and further advances our understanding of the complex factors influencing TB status concealment intentions. Overall, these findings can serve as a foundation for targeted interventions and policy development to promote open communication and enhance TB control strategies.
Conclusion
In this study, we found that over a quarter of the sample (28%) had intentions to conceal the TB status of their family members. Through multivariate model analysis, we identified several associations that contribute to our understanding of intentions to conceal the TB status of family members. Age emerged as a critical factor, with individuals aged 20–29, 30–39, and 40–49 being less likely to conceal the TB status of their family members compared to those aged 10–19. This suggests that as individuals grow older, they may become more aware of the importance of timely diagnosis and treatment for TB, leading to greater openness in disclosing the TB status of family members. Notably, the sex of participants did not significantly influence TB status concealment intentions, indicating that this practice is not particularly gender-dependent within the family unit. Regarding marital status, individuals living together were less likely to conceal the TB status of their family members compared to those who were never married, while widowed individuals showed a higher likelihood of concealment. These findings suggest that the type of marital arrangement may influence the disclosure intentions of TB status, potentially due to differences in family dynamics and support systems. The place of residence also played a role, with individuals in rural areas having a lower likelihood of TB status concealment compared to urban areas. This may be attributed to the closer-knit social networks and a stronger sense of community in rural settings, which fosters open communication about health conditions, including TB. Educational level was strongly associated with TB status disclosure, with higher educational attainment being linked to a greater likelihood of openly sharing the TB status of family members. This can be attributed to better health literacy and understanding of the importance of early detection and treatment among individuals with higher education levels. Religion also showed significant associations, with individuals following the Islamic faith being more likely to conceal the TB status of family members compared to Christians, while individuals of other religions were less likely to conceal. This highlights the need to address specific religious beliefs related to TB in targeted awareness campaigns and educational programs. Furthermore, individuals who read newspapers almost every day were more likely to conceal the TB status of their family members, which may indicate the presence of unique communication dynamics within this group that require further investigation. Regarding wealth status, individuals with greater financial resources had a lower likelihood of concealing the TB status of their family members compared to those with lower wealth. This suggests that improved access to healthcare facilities and resources, as well as better health awareness and education, may encourage individuals with higher financial resources to be more open about the TB status of their family members. Finally, the country of residence demonstrated significant associations with TB status concealment intentions, indicating that cultural and contextual factors play a role. For instance, individuals in Ghana, Lesotho, Malawi, Namibia, and Sao-Tome and Principe had higher odds of concealing the TB status of family members compared to Eswatini.
In conclusion, our study sheds light on the diverse factors influencing TB status concealment within families. These findings underscore the importance of targeted public health policies and interventions that consider demographic, socio-economic, and cultural factors to promote open communication about TB and enhance TB control strategies. Policymakers should focus on increasing awareness and understanding of TB, particularly among specific age groups, education levels, and religious affiliations. Addressing socio-cultural contexts, promoting health literacy, and engaging community leaders are essential steps in fostering a supportive environment for TB disclosure and management.